Save
When the weather turns cool and the days grow shorter, I always crave those nostalgic, comforting bakes that fill the kitchen with warmth and spice. Apple butter cheesecake is one of those desserts that perfectly captures the magic of autumn, combining creamy tangy cheesecake with a swirl of deep, spiced apple butter and a cinnamon graham crust that makes every bite feel like a celebration.
The first time I made this for a friendsgiving, everyone wanted seconds and the recipe ended up being requested more than anything else I brought that year.
Ingredients
- Graham cracker crumbs: create a crisp buttery base that supports the cheesecake
- Granulated sugar: provides a gentle sweetness and helps the crust hold together
- Cinnamon: boosts the coziness of both crust and filling look for Saigon cinnamon for the richest flavor
- Unsalted butter: holds the crust together and makes it golden and fragrant always select high quality butter for best taste
- Cream cheese: is the star for a dreamy texture and light tang use full fat and bring to room temperature for easy mixing
- Vanilla extract: rounds out the flavors with mellow fragrant notes pure extract is best for flavor
- Eggs: bind the batter and ensure a plush slice check for fresh firm eggs with no cracks
- Sour cream: lightens the cheesecake and adds the slightest tang look for one with minimal additives
- Apple butter: infuses the cheesecake with sweet and spiced apple notes homemade or high quality jarred versions both shine here
- Whipped cream and extra apple butter: optional for garnish but they add sweetness and visual appeal
- Fresh apple butter: is key so aim for one with lots of spices and a deep caramelized flavor
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Make the Crust:
- Stir graham cracker crumbs sugar and cinnamon in a medium bowl until evenly mixed then add melted butter and mix well until the mixture is damp and clumps easily. Press the mixture evenly into the base of a nine inch springform pan using the flat bottom of a glass or your hand for a level layer. Bake at three twenty five degrees Fahrenheit for ten minutes until lightly golden then cool while mixing the filling.
- Prepare the Cheesecake Filling:
- Beat room temperature cream cheese until smooth and fluffy scraping the bowl often. Mix in sugar in stages to ensure it dissolves completely and the batter is creamy. Add vanilla then eggs one at a time whipping just until combined. Blend in sour cream until smooth and glossy. Make sure all ingredients are fully incorporated but avoid overmixing which can create air bubbles.
- Add the Apple Butter:
- Fold the apple butter gently into the batter restoring a warm autumnly color and aroma. Pour the filling over your pre baked crust spreading it evenly with a spatula so it bakes flat.
- Swirl and Bake:
- Drop teaspoons of apple butter across the top then swirl gently with a table knife to create patterns. Set the pan in the center rack of the oven and bake for fifty five to sixty five minutes until the edges are set but the center jiggles lightly when shaken. A water bath can help with even baking and minimizing cracking.
- Cool and Chill:
- Let the cheesecake cool in the pan at room temperature for at least one hour to prevent shrinking. Refrigerate for at least four hours or up to overnight for best texture and easy slicing. For the cleanest slices use a sharp knife dipped in hot water and wiped clean between cuts. Top with extra apple butter or a swoosh of whipped cream before serving.
Save
My favorite thing about this recipe is the way apple butter swirls bake into the tangy cheesecake center — it always reminds me of my childhood trips to the apple orchard where every scent was cinnamon laced and comforting. I love sneaking a bit of extra apple butter in the batter for even richer ribbons
Storage Tips
Store leftover cheesecake covered in the refrigerator for up to four days. It also freezes beautifully for longer storage just wrap slices tightly in plastic and freeze for up to two months thaw overnight in the fridge. Let refrigerated slices sit out for fifteen minutes before serving for a creamy bite
Ingredient Substitutions
You can swap cinnamon graham crackers for plain and just add more cinnamon to the crust. Neufchâtel cheese works instead of regular cream cheese for a lighter result. Greek yogurt is a good stand in for sour cream. If apple butter is hard to find you can cook down unsweetened applesauce with extra cinnamon and cloves
Serving Suggestions
Pair with chai spiced tea mulled cider or dark roast coffee for a cozy dessert. Dress up slices with a dusting of cinnamon chopped nuts or caramel drizzle for even more fall flavor. It makes a fantastic finish after a roast chicken or pork dinner
Cultural Context
Apple butter has deep roots in the American Midwest and Appalachian regions where apple harvests were preserved by long slow cooking to create thick fragrant spreads. Cheesecake traditions arrive from European baking and blend beautifully with apple butter creating a dessert that feels both old fashioned and special. Serving this cheesecake is my way of celebrating those humble homey traditions
Recipe FAQs
- → What is the best type of jelly to use?
Grape or strawberry jelly works wonderfully, but feel free to use your personal favorite for the most enjoyable flavor.
- → Can I substitute homemade jelly?
Absolutely! Homemade jelly or preserves can provide an even fresher, more distinctive fruit taste in the cake.
- → Do I need to refrigerate leftovers?
Yes, store the cake in an airtight container in the refrigerator to keep the peanut butter frosting fresh and stable.
- → Is it possible to make this cake gluten-free?
You can replace all-purpose flour with a quality gluten-free flour blend; be sure to check other ingredients for gluten.
- → How can I achieve a smoother frosting?
Cream the peanut butter and butter until fluffy, then gradually add powdered sugar and milk, adjusting consistency as needed.